This negative review is no reflection on Moosejaw. They're a great company. I just happened to order a lousy product from them.I've been buying MSR products for 40+ years. This is the first one that's been a complete disappointment. On my second camping trip with this salt & pepper shaker, the snap-cover on the salt end broke off, making it unusable. I tried to rig a replacement stopper of some kind, but moisture still got in and ruined the salt, so I had no salt on the remaining four days of my hike. This is not just a matter of flavor; I rely on a certain amount of salt to keep my system in balance.