So, I bought the "charcoal" color against my better and truer black and brown nature, and I have to say that I'm a tad disappointed. It is not in any way shape or form charcoal, but rather is the color of moss. The disappointment tempers an otherwise pretty good review. The cut is trim (I bought a medium and I am 5'10" 160 lbs.) if not a bit long. This last bit is pretty inconvenient if you are layering, about an inch or two hang out the bottom of pretty much every thing I own. By itself you wouldn't think twice about it's length, only when under something not quite as long. Otherwise, it's pretty cozy and somewhat sweater like. I bit fuzzier than a sweater, but not in a fleecy way.