I bought these for ice climbing and I'm very happy with them. These gloves are warm, durable and very dextrous. I really like the design and they stay warm down to about 15 degrees just like they claim. So for all temperatures above that I give them 4 stars. The wrist has a solid constriction, and they don't come off and on easily, but I think this is a good thing more than a bad thing It also has a nice velcro strap that tucks underneath cuffs easily.